Taking a quick break from Retardo Montalbán to mention this.
Science-lite articles using “science says” verbiage are bothersome reification fallacies, since science doesn’t “say” anything; people do. On the other hand there’s a different kind of fallacious appeal smuggled through, since using “science says” doesn’t exactly invite criticism of whatever “it,” as an object, says.
One can reason with actual people—in this case, scientists—but not an abstraction. Counterpoints are preempted as soon as the phantom is invoked.
2 Comments
Science says your baby is a weed-eating holograph from Mars.
I guess my baby is also a socialist, according to Mother Jones.
I actually read that article knowing full well the level of stupidity that awaited me.